| 1863 - 1866 |
W H Mullen |
| 1867 |
W H Mullen & John Lee |
| 1868 |
John Lee |
| 1869 |
W H Mullen |
| 1870 - 1871 |
W H Smith |
| 1871 - 1873 |
W H Mullen |
| 1874 - 1875 |
W H Smith |
| 1876 |
H S Badgery |
| 1877 |
J Wolstenholme |
| 1878 |
John Lee |
| 1879 |
Alderman James |
| 1880 - 1881 |
J Fullford |
| 1882 |
J J Riley |
| 1883 |
James Pritchard |
| 1884 |
Alex Wilkinson |
| 1885 - 1886 |
Robert Hyndes |
| 1887 |
Robert Hyndes & Alex Wilkinson |
| 1888 |
Dr R J Pierce |
| 1889 - 1890 |
John Gillies |
| 1891 - 1893 |
R J Young |
| 1894 - 1897 |
Henry Crothers |
| 1898 - 1899 |
Alex Wilkinson |
| 1900 - 1901 |
T J Ribee |
| 1902 - 1903 |
Dr Frank Liddell |
| 1904 |
Colonel Wilkinson |
| 1905 |
W Mc Laughlin |
| 1906 |
W J Enright |
| 1907 - 1910 |
Major Walter Cracknell |
| 1911 |
F W Thursby |
| 1912 - 1913 |
W Mc Laughlin |
| 1914 - 1916 |
C J Mannall |
| 1917 - 1918 |
J B Thompson |
| 1919 |
Major Walter Cracknell |
| 1920 - 1923 |
H W Fry |
| 1924 |
H W Fry & J H F Waller |
| 1925 - 1926 |
J H F Waller |
| 1927 - 1928 |
H W Fry |
| 1929 - 1930 |
R L Pender |
| 1931 - 1935 |
A S McDonald |
| 1936 |
H W Fry |
| 1937 |
E E Morris |
| 1938 - 1939 |
A S Mc Donald |
| 1940 |
E C Scarlett & A S Mc Donald |
| 1941 - 1944 |
J V Kenedy |
| 5/7/1944 |
Municipality of Maitland Incorporated |
| 1945 |
A S McDonald |
| 7/12/1945 |
City of Maitland Proclaimed |
| 1946 - 1947 |
H T Skilton |
| 1948 - 1949 |
F O Fahey |
| 1950 |
A S McDonald |
| 1951 - 1952 |
J Harvey |
| 1953 |
M J Clyde |
| 1954 |
F O Fahey |
| 1955 - 1956 |
A S McDonald OBE |
| 1957 - 1965 |
H T Skilton |
| 1966 - 1967 |
W J Harvey |
| 1968 |
J G Wolstenholme |
| 1969 |
W J Harvey |
| 1970 - 1972 |
W R Walsh |
| 1973 - 1978 |
Cr Noel Unicomb |
| 1979 - 1983 |
Cr W R (Ron) Walsh |
| 1984 - 1985 |
Cr K W Guy |
| 1986 |
Cr P J Hughes |
| 1986 - 1990 |
Cr Peter Blackmore |
| 1990 |
Cr Ray Fairweather |
| 1991 |
Cr Graham Dunkley |
| 1992 - 1993 |
Cr R C (Bob) Gee |
| 1994 - Sep 1997 |
Cr John Martin |
| Sep 1997 - Nov 1997 |
Cr Henry Meskauskas |
| 1999 - 2017 |
Cr Peter Blackmore OAM |
| 2017 - 2021 |
Cr Loretta Baker |
